Demystifying Transfer Pricing: Strategies and Compliance

Trường Lăng

December 3, 2023


Demystifying Transfer Pricing: Strategies and Compliance

Trường Lăng

December 3, 2023

In the intricate web of international business transactions, the concept of transfer pricing emerges as a critical cornerstone. This practice involves pricing goods, services, and intellectual property exchanged between entities within the same multinational group. Join us as we unravel the complexities of transfer pricing, exploring its core concepts and significance in fostering fair and transparent global business transactions. Navigating this landscape is essential for multinational corporations seeking harmony between legal compliance and operational efficiency.

Types of Transfer Pricing

Arm’s Length Principle: Navigating Fair and Transparent Transactions

In the realm of global commerce, the Arm’s Length Principle stands as a cornerstone, guiding businesses toward fair and transparent transactions within a corporate group. This principle requires entities to set prices for transactions as if they were unrelated parties, preventing potential distortions in profits and tax obligations.

To illustrate, imagine a multinational corporation with subsidiaries in different countries. The Arm’s Length Principle prevents these subsidiaries from setting prices for goods or services in a way that artificially inflates or deflates profits to gain a tax advantage. Instead, prices should be set at a level that would be deemed fair and reasonable if the entities involved were independent businesses engaged in a similar transaction.

This approach not only promotes equity and integrity in financial dealings but also serves as a safeguard against potential tax evasion or manipulation. Adhering to the Arm’s Length Principle helps maintain a level playing field in international business transactions, fostering a global economic environment built on trust and accountability.

Common Methods: Exploring Transfer Pricing Approaches Used by Multinational Corporations

As businesses navigate the intricate landscape of multinational operations, they often employ specific methods for transfer pricing analysis, ensuring accuracy and compliance. One prevalent approach is the Comparable Uncontrolled Price (CUP) method, which benchmarks the price of a controlled transaction against an uncontrolled one in a comparable market. This method relies on external market data to establish a fair value for goods or services exchanged.

Another widely used method is the Cost Plus method, where the seller adds a predetermined percentage markup to the production cost, ensuring a reasonable profit margin. This approach is particularly suitable for tangible goods, allowing for a straightforward calculation of the arm’s length price.

In contrast, the Resale Price method focuses on the price at which a product is resold to an unrelated party. This method involves determining the resale price and deducting an appropriate gross profit margin to establish the transfer price.

Types of Transfer Pricing
As businesses navigate the intricate landscape of multinational operations, they often employ specific methods for transfer pricing analysis. Source: Internet

Compliance Challenges: Unraveling the Complexities in Effective Transfer Pricing Analysis

While these methods offer flexibility to address diverse business scenarios, their application requires a nuanced understanding of regulatory requirements, accounting standards, and the specific nature of the transactions involved. Navigating compliance challenges becomes paramount, demanding meticulous documentation, thorough benchmarking, and the ability to adapt to evolving international standards. In the competitive landscape of multinational operations, a comprehensive understanding and application of various transfer pricing approaches are crucial for sustainable and responsible business practices.

Transfer Pricing Activities in FDI Enterprises

The Complexities of FDI Dynamics in Transfer Pricing

In the intricate landscape of international business, Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) enterprises encounter distinctive challenges and opportunities in navigating the realm of transfer pricing. FDI dynamics frequently revolve around transactions between parent companies and subsidiaries, demanding meticulous consideration of pricing mechanisms. This process aims to align with regulatory standards while optimizing financial outcomes, reflecting the delicate balance required in international financial transactions.

Case Study – Coca-Cola Vietnam’s Transfer Pricing Conundrum

A notable case is Coca-Cola’s experience in Vietnam, where the Ho Chi Minh City Tax Department observed continuous losses reported from 1992 to the end of 2012. Despite robust sales growth exceeding 25% annually, the accumulated losses surpassed the initial investment capital, theoretically suggesting the possibility of bankruptcy. However, rather than scaling down, Coca-Cola invested an additional $300 million in 2012 to expand its operations, prompting scrutiny from Vietnamese tax authorities regarding a potential transfer pricing case. Despite the challenges in proving such instances, Coca-Cola Vietnam began reporting profits and paying corporate income tax in 2013.

This scenario exemplifies the intricate nature of transfer pricing cases faced by FDI enterprises, prompting Vietnamese tax authorities to conduct inspections and clarify transfer pricing behaviors. Yet, many cases remain undiscovered or face ongoing suspicion, with inspections and conclusive findings posing significant difficulties and challenges.

Coca-Cola Vietnam's Transfer Pricing Conundrum
Coca-Cola Vietnam’s Transfer Pricing Conundrum. Source: Coca-Cola Vietnam

Regulatory Influences on FDI Enterprise Transfer Pricing

To navigate this complex web of decisions, a profound understanding of the regulatory landscape is essential. Local and international laws wield substantial influence over the transfer pricing decisions of FDI enterprises. Globally, governments are intensifying efforts to counter profit shifting and tax evasion, enacting stringent regulations to ensure transactions are fair and transparent. FDI enterprises must meticulously assess the legal frameworks of both their home country and the host country to align with evolving compliance requirements.

Anti-Transfer Pricing in Vietnam

Regulatory Reinforcement – Decree 132/2020/ND-CP

On 5 November 2020, Vietnam’s government enacted a critical regulatory update with the issuance of Decree 132/2020/ND-CP, reshaping the landscape of transfer pricing. Effective from 20 December 2020 onward, Decree 132 introduces nuanced changes applicable to the financial year 2020 and beyond.

Redefined Related Party Parameters

Decree 132 introduces a revamped definition of ‘related party’ based on ownership thresholds, retaining the 25% criterion. Under this decree, an enterprise and an individual are deemed related parties if engaged in specific transactions during a tax period. These transactions include transferring or receiving contributed capital equivalent to at least 25% of the enterprise owner’s capital and borrowing or lending a minimum of 10% of the capital contributed by the enterprise owner.

Enhanced Arm’s-Length Range

Decree 132 raises the acceptable arm’s-length range, now spanning from the 35th percentile to the 75th percentile. This adjustment, a tightening from the previous 25th to 75th percentile range under Decree 20, results in a 10% increase in the minimum threshold. Consequently, taxpayers must recalibrate their transfer pricing strategies for financial year 2020 onwards to align with this more stringent range.

Exemptions and Conditions

Decree 132 outlines specific conditions exempting taxpayers from preparing comprehensive transfer pricing documentation while still adhering to other aspects of the decree. Exemption criteria include having revenue below VND 50 billion and total value of related-party transactions below VND 30 billion, entering into an Advance Pricing Agreement (APA) with submitted annual APA report(s), achieving specified earnings ratios based on business functions, or engaging solely in domestic related party transactions with identical tax rates and no tax incentives.

Anti Transfer Pricing in Vietnam
Vietnam’s government enacted a critical regulatory update with the issuance of Decree 132/2020/ND-CP, reshaping the landscape of transfer pricing. Source: Internet

Final Thoughts

Navigating the intricate realm of international business demands a keen understanding of transfer pricing intricacies. Reflecting on the role of transfer pricing in optimizing global operations and ensuring compliance, it becomes evident that mastering these complexities is indispensable. As you grapple with these challenges, Viettonkin stands ready to unravel the intricacies and guide your business through the evolving landscape of transfer pricing. Elevate your business by leveraging Viettonkin‘s expertise to seamlessly navigate transfer pricing challenges and foster responsible, profitable international business practices. Connect with Viettonkin, your trusted partner in ensuring compliance in international business transactions.

Download our Latest Ebook about Real Estate and Property!

Real estate holds a pivotal position in the development of a country, not only via the spillover impacts on other economic sectors such as construction, manufacturing, tourism, finance and banking etc. but also affecting the social dynamic by mobilizing the residency and infrastructure system. Foreign direct investment in real estate (RFDI) in Vietnam has a long running history and is unique in that it is largely dominated by the private sector compared to other industries which usually still have a rather large Government involvement. International capital has consistently been selecting real estate as the destination of choice, given that RDI has always been in the top 2 and 3 for volume inflow over the last 10 years, even throughout extremely turbulent periods such as COVID-19, per the General Statistics Office of Vietnam’s (GSO) data. Find out more in this ebook edition.

Tải cuốn ebook mới nhất về nền kinh tế số Việt Nam!

The digital economy of Vietnam has been fueled and accelerated by the global digital trends and the pandemic Covid-19. The movement of digital transformation is underway in every corner of Vietnamese life, strongly influencing the way people do things. Digital economy is the future of the Vietnam economy. Realizing the potential of the digital economy, the Vietnam government has issued policies, guidelines and created legal frameworks to support and further enhance this economy. In this ebook edition, the digital economy is looked at from different angles. Perspectives from the key elements comprising Vietnam digital economy are examined and discovered.

Our Happy Clients